The Pros and Cons of Pumping as a Surrogate

Be a surrogate

You may be aware of the many health benefits of breastfeeding, which is why when you had your own children you were determined to perfect the latch, master the hold, and get your babies that liquid gold.

Now that your journey as a gestational surrogate is underway, you may begin to consider whether you feel as strongly about pumping as you did about breastfeeding. Or perhaps you have not yet really begun to consider whether you want to pump for this journey. Fear not, we have created a short list of pros and cons to help you sort out whether pumping as a surrogate is right for you.

Pros of Pumping As a Gestational Surrogate

1) Surrogacy Pumping Community Already Exists

Although the idea of pumping as a surrogate may be new to you, there are many women who have been sharing their ideas and providing support for one another for many years. A quick Google search results in dozens of online resources and communities, all devoted to pumping surrogates. These networks are a rich resource capable of providing you with both practical insight and inspiration. We especially recommend checking out this Facebook group centered around pumping after a surrogacy pregnancy.

2) Pumping for your Health

Pumping promotes nearly all of the healing and health benefits that breastfeeding does. We say “nearly all” because science has yet to decipher how much of the healing process triggered by breastfeeding is a result of snuggling and interacting with an adorable infant. That said, it looks as if pumping will help with your fourth trimester recovery by shrinking your uterus, burning extra calories, and helping reduce uterine bleeding after birth. Plus, pumping does release oxytocin, a powerful hormone linked to love, trust, and pair bonding.

3) Breast Milk is Liquid Gold

Breast Milk is full of antibodies that help babies to fight off viruses and bacteria. The medicinal benefits to your surrobaby are not diminished by the milk, having been pumped then presented via a bottle. The milk you provide will help bolster your surrobaby’s immunity, and decrease episodes of diarrheal illness, ear infections, severe lower respiratory tract infections, diabetes, obesity, and sudden infant death syndrome. No wonder the American Academy of Pediatrics considers breastmilk the most 'optimal form of nutrition’ for infants.

4) Pumping is Easier than Ever

You may have felt overwhelmed by the prospect of pumping when you had your own children. The equipment can look a little intimidating at first and some pumps look downright bulky. The great news is that pumping has come a long way in just the past few years. Consider The Willow™ Pump- it is the only wearable breast pump that fits in your bra with no external tubes, cords, or dangling bottles to hold you back. You can pump while vacuuming, shopping at Target, you name it!

5) Pumping Compensation

Although compensation is likely not one of your primary motivations, it is worth mentioning that many surrogates are indeed compensated for the milk they pump. This is in addition to your All-In Surrogate Care & Compensation Package. Check your contract or surrogacy agreement for the compensation details associated with supplying breast milk.

6) You Can Donate Your Milk And Make A Difference

Many of our surrogates have questions about donating breast milk after their surrogacy pregnancy, if their intended parents do not request them to pump for their surrobabe. Donating human milk can have a life-saving impact for babies born everyday. In the United States, 450,000 babies are born prematurely every year, and others struggle with serious illness. These fragile babies will survive and thrive thanks to the generosity of human milk donors who give the critical nourishment they need. Learn more about how to donate your breast milk after your surrogacy journey from Lenna Gregory with Mothers' Milk Bank.

Alright, now that we have covered a few reason pros, let’s get to the cons and chat a bit about why you may not want to pump as surrogate.

Cons Pumping As a Gestational Surrogate

1) Pumping is Work

As mentioned previously, although it is easier now than ever, pumping can take some work and it may still cause multiple interruptions to your day and nightly schedule. For some busy mamas, fitting this additional task into their schedules is just not a possibility, but that is okay! You have given your Intended Parents an incredible gift. If you are not excited about pumping, it is very likely that they will understand.

2) Shipping Milk is Tricky

Unless your Intended Parents live nearby or are “setting up camp” in your neck of the woods for a few months after delivery, you are going to have to not only pump your breast milk but also ship it. Since breast milk is perishable you will have to follow some strict instructions to assure that it arrives fit for consumption, including the application of dry ice, and only shipping on certain days of the week. Check out the helpful guide created by All Things Surrogacy for pro tips on how to ship breast milk.

Make certain you and your Intended Parents have discussed not only compensation for breast milk but also reimbursement for costs associated with the shipping it. You may be surprised how expensive it is to ship a week’s worth of milk cross-country.

3) Uninterested Intended Parents

You may not see this one coming but even if you are open to pumping, there is no guarantee that your Intended Parents will be receptive to the arrangement. Some IPs prefer to stick to formula and not deal with the hassle of breast milk logistics. If you find yourself in this situation- willing and wanting to pump but with uninterested Intended Parents, consider donating your milk to a milk bank. Many hospitals also are interested in donated breast milk for premature babies. Learn more about the process to donate your milk with Mothers' Milk Bank of North Texas.

Ultimately the decision to pump as a surrogate is entirely yours. As with many aspects of motherhood, infant nutrition can inspire heated debate. Our hope is that surrogates feel empowered to do what is right for them, their family and their circumstances. Because again, you have already done a lot! It is okay if you want to keep going or take a break.

Check out Stanford Medicine's helpful video on maximizing the milk from breastfeeding.

Bosom Buddies also has some great resources and articles on breastfeeding babies.

Mothers' Milk Bank: Learn more about how to donate your breast milk

Calling All Surrogates
Are you a woman who enjoyed a healthy and successful pregnancy? Do you have friends or family who have suffered from infertility or need assistance from someone else to build their family? Have you ever considered the role you could play in helping someone else build their family - as a surrogate? Learn more about the process of helping someone else's dream of building a family come true. We would love to talk with you.

Be a surrogate